Galileo's Mistake

A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church

Leesfragment
€12,29
  • The
  • modern
  • understanding
  • of
  • the
  • notorious
  • 1633
  • trial
  • of
  • Galileo
  • is
  • that
  • of
  • Science
  • and
  • Reason
  • persecuted
  • by
  • Ignorance
  • and
  • Superstition-of
  • Galileo
  • as
  • a
  • lonely,
  • courageous
  • freethinker
  • oppressed
  • by
  • a
  • reactionary
  • and
  • anti-intellectual
  • institution
  • fearful
  • of
  • losing
  • its
  • power
  • and
  • influence.
  • But
  • is
  • this
  • an
  • accurate
  • picture? In
  • his
  • provocative
  • reexamination
  • of
  • one
  • of
  • the
  • turning
  • points
  • in
  • the
  • history
  • of
  • science
  • and
  • thought,
  • Wade
  • Rowland
  • contends
  • that
  • the
  • dispute
  • concerned
  • an
  • infinitely
  • more
  • profound
  • question:
  • What
  • is
  • truth
  • and
  • how
  • can
  • we
  • know
  • it?
  • Rowland
  • demonstrates
  • that
  • Galileo’s
  • mistake
  • was
  • to
  • insist
  • that
  • science-and
  • only
  • science-provides
  • the
  • truth
  • about
  • reality.
  • The
  • Church
  • rejected
  • this
  • idea,
  • declaring
  • that
  • while
  • science
  • is
  • valid,
  • truth
  • is
  • a
  • metaphysical
  • issue-beyond
  • physics-and
  • it
  • involves
  • such
  • matters
  • as
  • meaning
  • and
  • purpose,
  • which
  • are
  • unquantifiable
  • and
  • therefore
  • not
  • amenable
  • to
  • scientific
  • analysis.
  • In
  • asserting
  • the
  • primacy
  • of
  • science
  • on
  • the
  • territory
  • of
  • truth,
  • Galileo
  • strayed
  • into
  • the
  • theological
  • realm,
  • an
  • act
  • that
  • put
  • him
  • squarely
  • on
  • a
  • warpath
  • with
  • the
  • Church.
  • The
  • outcome
  • would
  • change
  • the
  • world.
  • Wade
  • Rowland’s
  • thoughtful
  • exploration
  • promises
  • to
  • disarm
  • the
  • most
  • stubborn
  • of
  • skeptics
  • and
  • make
  • for
  • scintillating debate.
1 of 187
pro-mbooks3 : libris